At this point, I would like to argue that the loss of line attribution can create a collective character that carries the common apathy that young generation carries. Meanwhile, current papers explore the portrayals of characters, the relations among various characters and the profound presence of the cafe in A Clean, Well-lighted Place.
Next, the old waiter in the story who holds sympathy and has more sexual abstention creates a contrast to this collective representation. A lot of young people share the same apathetic attitude. This logic explains why a clean and well-lighted place appeals to thoughtful people with sexual dignity.
Through being clean, the cafe welcomes new people to come and feel comfortable yet they are obliged to keep this place clean too. And through the contrast of the two attitudes, I aim at building a powerful connection between a clean, well-lighted place and qualities like compassion and abstention.
In order to demonstrate this thesis, I will categorize the characters into two types. Oppositely, the old waiter shows apparent appreciation of a clean and well-lighted place.
Otto Reiner insists that these two lines are said by one waiter Kerner Furthermore, I will elaborate on the attitudes of these two types of people toward the clean and well-lighted cafe. Here mutual respect is generated, which serves as the basis of sympathy.
Hence, people with sympathy become uncommon and therefore the minority of society. The first type is the characters who are incapable of sympathizing with others and who have less sexual temperance while the second type is the opposite.
We remain ignorant if they are the same waiter. Against this background, this essay claims that the theme of this short story is that a clean, well-lighted place is a place for people with more sympathy and sexual abstinence to retreat to, namely, a fortress for these people to resist the selfish and self-indulgent lifestyle pursued by the majority of society.
On the contrary, the old waiter is more sympathetic to others and has more sexual temperance. At that point they are both in a hurry to engage in sexual acts. Works Cited Bennett, Warren. Accordingly, a clean and well-lighted cafe becomes a final place for them to stay and enjoy their life which is rebellious to the popular indulgent and indifferent lifestyle in society.
However, the absence of subjects here generates a collective representation which suggests that this kind of apathetic people is common. Here this minority group of people calls for a conservative and respectful place that matches their personality. Clear lighting also provides them with the possibility to read and see their friends clearly.
In this short story, a lack of sympathy can be found in quite a few characters. Here clearness entails dignity and a clearer mind. The Finca Vigia Edition. Clear lighting in public places prevents visible sex. To illustrate, apathetic common people do not acclaim a clean, well-lighted place.
Therefore the old waiter, who is able to appreciate and practice the dignity that sexual temperance engenders, bears sympathy as well as sexual temperance.
Similarly, the cleanness of the cafe engenders a sense of caring. In the last conversation among waiters, apart from the considerate old waiter and the apathetic young waiter, another waiter joins the conversation. This indicates his cavalier attitude towards sexual indulgence.A Clean Well Lighted Place Essay Examples.
An Analysis of Ernest Hemingway's A Clean, Well-Lighted Place. 1, words. An Analysis of the Three Main Characters in the Novel A Clean, Well-Lighter Place by Ernest Hemingway. 1, words. 3 pages. Biography and Works of Ernest Hemingway.
- “ A Clean, Well-Lighted Place” by Ernest Hemingway is a simplistic short story in which he narrates a scene in a Cafe, where the main characters are two waiters and an old man. In the story, Hemingway hardly created a background for his characters, but this was part of his minimalist writing style.
Dec 07, · Ernest Hemingway’s famous short story A Clean, Well-lighted Place gave rise to controversy over the attribution of lines in the dialogue among the waiters. Contemporary essays debate whether the emendation of A Clean, Well-lighted Place betrays Hemingway’s intention regarding line attribution.
Meanwhile, current papers. Presents a critique of the short story "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place," by Ernest Hemingway. Debate caused by Charles Scribner Jr.'s emendation of the short story in the year ; Focus on the dialogue between the story's main characters.
An Analysis of the Main Characters in a Clean, Well-Lighted Place by Ernest Hemingway. The title "A Clean, Well-Lighted Place" reveals not only irony but the major themes of solidarity and dignity in the face of the unknowable.
Irony: the title is .Download